Economists S.T.E.P. Forward

The Cheerful Science Offers Circuit Breakers and Hope

← Back to Home

Beyond the Doom Loop

For many years, Britain has been trapped in a self-fulfilling “doom loop.” Productivity growth has stagnated. Structural health and disability expenditures have risen sharply. And, despite historically high tax rates, the fiscal backdrop just gets worse. Debt interest burdens have escalated, and there are accelerating pressures on the public purse from climate change and worsening geopolitical tensions. The despair feeds higher gilt yields, suppresses private spending and growth, and ultimately shrinks the tax base. Governments then feel forced to shrink into austerity mode, reinforcing the weakness in potential growth and accelerating the downward spiral.

We all know that breaking out of this vicious cycle requires more than incremental adjustments; it demands radical, innovative change.

Who knows whether the Burnham administration will, or can, deliver the required policy changes within a timeframe, and with consequences, that are acceptable to an impatient, irascible electorate. Initial signs are encouraging but there is no guarantee of success.

What follows is a humble economist’s attempt to identify a structural reform agenda that addresses the macro changes that need to happen. It does not claim originality of policy proposals but, in exploring feasible outcomes through macro-finance models, reveals that we can dare to dream.

S.T.E.P. Forward

Enter a hypothetical S.T.E.P. platform (Switch, Tech, Empower,Purpose) - a package of four targeted structural reforms designed for short-term implementation (Years 1-3) as a foundation for a long-run growth revival without fiscal headaches:

  1. S = Switch and substitute revenue sources: Rebalance the tax burden from income to wealth. This includes cutting employee National Insurance contributions, funded by equalising the tax treatment of unearned investment and capital income with earned income. Land taxes will also play a role in re-incentivising work and thus labour force participation. Focus on immovables, anticipate and address behavioural avoidance.
  2. T = Tech focus: Put AI, robotics, digitalisation, biotech and science at the heart of government, education and worker skillsets. Deploy co-investment (public/private, UK/European) vehicles via a National Wealth Fund and a British Business Bank. Ensure that such vehicles enable the scaling of superstars and are not simply shelters for unproductive zombie companies.Take advantage of homegrown expertise in AI, biotech, quantum computing and financial services to maximise employment opportunities, and above all, significantly raise productivity growth. Promoting innovation clusters and accelerating diffusion of new ideas will be key.
  3. E = Empowering Regions: Fully activate the revived National Economic Council. Empower mayors as economic actors, not simply Town Hall administrators. Joined-up thinking and action across regions, coupled with enhanced democratic legitimacy through devolution, will raise productivity and boost both business and consumer confidence.Tackle NHS/Social Care overlaps efficiently at regional level.
  4. P = Purposeful participation: Engage fully in welfare reform. Replace duplicate, adversarial assessment processes with simplified Health-to-Work gateways. Substitute low-level cash top-ups with direct-access vouchers and immediate occupational therapy. Proactively support NEETS at regional and national levels.

The Self-Financing Virtuous Cycle

%%{init: {
  'theme': 'base',
  'themeVariables': {
    'fontSize': '32px',
    'fontFamily': 'Arial, sans-serif',
    'primaryColor': '#dceef8',
    'primaryTextColor': '#102a43',
    'primaryBorderColor': '#2980b9',
    'lineColor': '#2980b9',
    'edgeLabelBackground': '#ffffff',
    'clusterBkg': 'transparent',
    'clusterBorder': '#2980b9'
  },
  'flowchart': {
    'htmlLabels': true,
    'nodeSpacing': 30,
    'rankSpacing': 40
  }
}}%%

flowchart LR
    subgraph STEP["THE S.T.E.P. PILLARS"]
        direction TB
        S["SWITCH<br/>Tax Rebalancing"]
        T["TECH<br/>TFP GenAI"]
        E["EMPOWER<br/>Devolution"]
        P["PURPOSE<br/>Welfare Reform"]
    end

    S --> Hope
    T --> Hope
    E --> Hope
    P --> Hope

    subgraph CYCLE[" "]
        direction TB
        Hope["Boost Sentiment<br/>& Hope"]
        Growth["Accelerate Potential<br/>Real GDP Growth"]
        TaxBase["Expand Tax Base<br/>& Structural Savings"]
        Vigilantes["Ward Off Bond Vigilantes<br/>Real Gilt Yields fall"]
        Decay["Sustainable Debt Decay<br/>GDP Growth exceeds Financing Rate"]

        Hope --> Growth
        Growth --> TaxBase
        TaxBase --> Vigilantes
        Vigilantes --> Decay
    end

    classDef processBox fill:#dceef8,stroke:#2980b9,stroke-width:2px,color:#102a43;
    class S,T,E,P,Hope,Growth,TaxBase,Vigilantes,Decay processBox;

    style STEP fill:transparent,stroke:#2980b9,stroke-width:2px,color:#102a43
    style CYCLE fill:transparent,stroke:none

The core attraction of this S.T.E.P. platform lies in its inbuilt self-financing design together with its capacity to break out of the doom loop and enter a reinforcing virtuous cycle.

Crucially, as confidence returns, a positive feedback loop takes hold. Improved sentiment crowds in private spending, labour force participation stabilises via health-to-work pathways, and GenAI adoption lifts baseline productivity. The strategy protects public finances in the short term and builds a solid foundation for future sustainability.

The resulting expansion of the real tax base, combined with falling sovereign borrowing yields and narrowing risk premia, wards off bond vigilantes and secures a sustainable, long-run fiscal dividend.


The Macro Modelling Framework

To demonstrate that a positive outcome is feasible, we model the policy platform in the context of standard growth and public finance models.

Supply-Side Potential Growth

Aggregate output \(Y_t\) is governed by a Cobb-Douglas production function with labour-augmenting technological progress \(A_t\):

\[Y_t = K_t^\alpha (A_t L_t)^{1-\alpha}\]

Taking logarithms and time derivatives yields the standard growth accounting identity for potential real GDP growth (\(g_t\)):

\[g_t = \alpha g_{K,t} + (1-\alpha)(g_{A,t} + g_{L,t})\]

where:
\(\alpha = 0.40\) represents the profit share (capital share of aggregate income), calibrated from Penn World Table (PWT) 11.0 estimates

\(g_{A,t}\) is labour-augmenting Total Factor Productivity (TFP) growth, which accelerates asymptotically from an initial OBR baseline of 0.9% to a GenAI-boosted steady-state target of 2.25%

\(g_{L,t}\) is labour force growth, stabilised at 0.4%–0.5% via PIP health-to-work and NEETs reforms

\(g_{K,t}\) is capital stock growth, which endogenously converges toward the Solow Balanced Growth Path (BGP) equilibrium: \(g_K^* = g_A + g_L = 2.6\%\).

Capital Returns & Gilt Yields

The gross Marginal Product of Capital (\(\text{MPK}\)) and the net private real return (\(r_{\text{priv}}\)) are derived from the aggregate capital-output ratio \(K/Y\) , based on PWT 11.0 estimates for the UK:

\[\text{MPK}_t = \alpha \left(\frac{Y_t}{K_t}\right) \approx 0.40 \times \left(\frac{1}{4.8}\right) \approx 8.3\%\]

\[r_{\text{priv},t} = \text{MPK}_t - \delta = 8.3\% - 5.0\% = 3.3\%\]

where \(\delta = 5.0\%\) is the assumed fixed rate of capital depreciation.

Public sector real borrowing yields (\(r_{\text{gov},t}\)) differ from private returns due to a market risk/convenience wedge (\(\pi_{\text{risk},t}\)):

\[r_{\text{priv},t} = r_{\text{gov},t} + \pi_{\text{risk},t}\]

Initial conditions for \(r_{\text{gov}} = 3.1\%\) use the current 10-year nominal gilt yield of ~5.1% less assumed inflation expectations of 2.0%.

\(r_{\text{gov}}\) falls toward 1.0% as fiscal credibility is established with both domestic and international financial markets.

Debt Sustainability Mechanics

The sovereign debt-to-GDP ratio (\(b_t\)) evolves dynamically:

\[b_t = (1 + r_{\text{gov},t} - g_t) b_{t-1} + pd_t\]

\[\Delta b_t = (r_{\text{gov},t} - g_t) b_{t-1} + pd_t\]

where \(pd_t\) is the primary deficit ratio. The Sustainability Gap is defined as \(g_t - r_{\text{gov},t}\). Currently, Britain is in an unstable regime, signified by a negative gap. But, as the S.T.E.P program takes effect, the gap reverses into positive territory \(g > r_{\text{gov}}.\) The economy then generates a positive growth dividend that naturally erodes the debt ratio, allowing structural primary surpluses (\(pd < 0\)) to accelerate debt reduction.


Simulation Results & Horizon Projections

The following simulation is calibrated using Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) baseline figures for 2025/26 and estimates made in Penn World Tables 11.0.

Initial conditions are as follows: \(b_{2026} = 94.0\%\) of GDP, initial primary deficit \(= 1.4\%\) of GDP, debt interest payments \(= 2.9\%\) of GDP, GDP growth \(= 1.5\%\)yoy.

As expected, a successful and sustained S.T.E.P. implementation leads the UK toward a desirable long-run steady state, a happy place.

Two panel chart showing Solow potential growth convergence and declining government debt dynamics.

Macroeconomic Growth Acceleration and Fiscal Sustainability Trajectory
Illustrative Macro-Fiscal Simulation: Benchmarks NOT Forecasts
Initialised using OBR and Penn World Tables 11.0 estimates
2027 2028 2029 2030s (Avg) Long Run (2040s+)
Growth & Supply Side %yoy
Real GDP 1.4% 1.8% 2.1% 2.7% 2.6%
Labour Force 0.6% 0.4% 0.4% 0.5% 0.4%
Capital Stock 1.2% 1.7% 2.1% 2.7% 2.6%
Total Factor Productivity 0.9% 1.4% 1.7% 2.2% 2.2%
Real Interest Rates %
Private Sector Net Real Return 3.3% 3.3% 3.3% 3.2% 3.2%
Risk Premium 0.2% 1.1% 1.6% 2.0% 2.2%
Government Real Funding Rate 3.1% 2.2% 1.8% 1.2% 1.0%
Government Finances % of GDP
Primary Deficit 1.4% 0.6% 0.0% −0.6% −1.2%
Debt Interest Costs 2.9% 2.1% 1.7% 1.2% 0.8%
Headline Deficit 4.3% 2.7% 1.7% 0.6% −0.4%
Debt Ratio, end-period 97.0% 98.0% 97.7% 78.4% 55.3%
Sustainability Gap −1.7% −0.4% 0.4% 1.5% 1.6%
Notes & Model Specifications:

  1. Macro Supply: Production technology assumes a Cobb-Douglas format with profit share \(\alpha = 40\%\), capital depreciation \(\delta = 5.0\%\), and \(K/Y \approx 4.8\).
    Gross \(\text{MPK} = \alpha (Y/K) = 8.3\%\)

  2. Debt & Inflation: Inflation expectations anchored at \(\pi = 2.0\%\); corresponding nominal 10-year funding rate is \(i = r_{\text{gov}} + \pi = 5.1\%\) in 2027

  3. Sustainability Gap: Real GDP Growth less Government Real Funding Rate (\(g - r_{\text{gov}}\)).
    Positive values (\(g > r_{\text{gov}}\)) indicate dynamic stability, negative values imply instability

  4. Solow Balanced Growth Path: Final column represents the model’s steady state
    \(g_K^* = g_A + g_L = 2.6\%\), yielding \(g^* = 2.6\%\)

Take That

Britain could limp along towards the next election. But who wants that, and the scary political dangers posed for socio-economic wellbeing? There is clearly appetite for radical change and the S.T.E.P framework offers workable ideas. For those worried about whether it all adds up, the macro-finance simulations show that it can - in terms of combining strong growth, better living standards, stable inflation and sustainable public finances.

Boosting productivity holds the key to exiting the Doom Loop. Easy to say but notoriously harder to do. AI and similarly progressive technologies offer a lifeline. But while tech creation is essential, adoption and diffusion are necessary. In this regard, rebalancing taxes, meaningful devolution, offering purpose and participation for all potential workers, thoroughly reforming the health and social care system jointly unlock the door to the Virtuous Cycle, leading to the happy place that we all crave.

Further Reading

Resolution Foundation (2025) Call of duties

Resolution Foundation (2026) See it. Say it. Sort it: How to reset Britain’s economic policy

Resolution Foundation (2026) Mountain Climbing

Resolution Foundation (2026) Lost in Transition

IFS (2025) How to fix property taxes

IPPR (2026) Turning energy support into investment leverage

Joseph Rowntree Foundation (2026) Tackle economic failures at root to ease pressure on Universal Credit

Centre for Cities (2026) Fiscal Devolution for England

Re:State (2026) Taxing for Take-Off: A new plan for fiscal devolution

New Economics Foundation (2026) Reclaiming Our Regional Economies

Centre for Policy Studies (2026) Patently Absurd: Why Britain is No Longer an Innovation Nation

Centre for Policy Studies (2026) Why Raising Capital Taxes Won’t Work

Centre for Policy Studies (2026) PA Productivity Toolkit for Britain

UK Government (2026) No10 North/revived National Economic Council

UK Government (2026 update) The Timms Review: Interim

UK Government (2026 update) The Milburn Report: Interim

Commission on Funding of Care and Support (2011) Dilnot Report

King’s Fund (2014) Barker Commission: A New Settlement for Health and Social Care

Care Quality Commission (2025) State of Care 2024/25

HC Health and Social Care Committee (2025) Adult Social Care Reform: The Cost of Inaction

Casey Commission (2025-2028) Adult Social Care

Penn World Tables 11.0

OBR Fiscal Risks & Sustainability (Jul 2026)